"Near Enemies" of Advice

Advice

Far Enemy

Eating all your muffins is a far enemy of baking you muffins

Advice

Near Enemy

Baking you muffins with an ingredient you're allergic to is a near enemy of baking you muffins

Advice

Near Enemies of Advice

Some things that are like advice, but are not.

Advice

Opinions

are Near Enemies of Advice

  • Advice: recommendation with reasons
  • Opinion: recommendation without reasons
Advice

When they give you opinions

Ask "why" to convert the opinion to advice

Advice

Megamobbing

is a Near Enemy of Asking Advice

  • Megamobbing: add more people to the decision making team
  • Asking advice: ask for recommendations (with reasons), but do not grow the decision making team
Advice

Asking Permission

is a Near Enemy of Asking Stakeholders for Advice

  • Asking Permission: "this impacts you, may we do X?"
  • Asking Stakeholders for Advice: "this impacts you, can you tell me more?"
Advice

We can ask for Advice

without giving up our autonomy

Keep control of your own decision by making sure:

  • the adviser also shares their reasoning
    • so you can determine if their recommendation is relevant
  • you make the final decision without the adviser
Advice